The “dance hall western whore” stereotype, widely popularized by Hollywood, is a misleading and historically inaccurate portrayal of women working in saloons and dance halls during the American West. While some women did work as prostitutes, a distinct class of entertainer existed whose primary role was to socialize with and encourage men to spend money, not to provide sexual services. 

The lives of dance hall girls

• Distinct role: In most towns, a clear distinction existed between saloon or dance hall girls and prostitutes, who were sometimes called “soiled doves” or “painted ladies”. A dance hall girl’s job was to dance with lonely men and flirt to encourage them to buy drinks, for which the women received a commission.
• A respectable living: In the Old West, where men far outnumbered women, dance hall work offered a respectable and often lucrative path to independence. Some women earned more in a night than a working man did in a month. Many women worked only temporarily before marrying, sometimes to a man they met at the dance hall.

• Protection by owners: Saloon owners had a financial interest in protecting their dance hall girls. They often demanded that customers treat the women with respect, and men who harassed or mistreated them could be ostracized or banned from the establishment. Many women carried concealed weapons for self-defense.
• Theatrical fashion: In contrast to Hollywood’s revealing costumes, historical dance hall girls wore eye-catching but generally modest clothing. They dressed in bright, frilly dresses with colorful petticoats, often with bodices cut low and shorter hemlines to make dancing easier. 

The reality of prostitution

• Separate class: Prostitutes occupied a lower class than saloon and dance hall girls, though it could be a higher-paying profession than other limited options for women, such as being a seamstress or laundress.
• High risks: Life as a prostitute was far more dangerous, with high risks of violence, disease, addiction, and abuse. They faced social stigma and often died in poverty.
• Working conditions: Prostitutes worked in different types of establishments, from high-end parlors run by influential madams to small “cribs” or as streetwalkers. Some madams were highly successful and well-known in their communities.
• Societal hypocrisy: Despite being legally outlawed, prostitution was tolerated and even taxed by many Western towns, with brothels often contributing significantly to municipal revenue. “Respectable” women shunned prostitutes, but their husbands often frequented brothels. 

In the American Old West, a “dance hall girl” and a “whore” were not the same, though the line could be blurry and the popular image of them has been conflated by Hollywood. The terms describe distinct roles, and not all women working in saloons were prostitutes. 

Dance hall girl

• Role: A dance hall or saloon girl was primarily an entertainer. Her job was to socialize, dance with male customers, and encourage them to buy drinks. The dance hall earned money from the dance tickets and the drinks the customers purchased, and the girls earned a commission on these sales.
• Income: For many women, this was an honest and lucrative profession that provided them with independence in the male-dominated frontier. It was not uncommon for a popular girl to earn more in a single night than a working man did in a month.
• Social status: Despite their flirtatious roles, most dance hall girls were not “fallen women.” In fact, some were treated as ladies by their patrons. Many were able to use their work to meet and marry respectable men. 

Prostitute

• Role: Prostitutes, also known as “soiled doves,” “shady ladies,” or “painted ladies,” engaged in sex work for a living. This was a distinct profession, separate from being a dance hall girl, though the two fields sometimes intersected, particularly in the roughest frontier towns.
• Social status: The social hierarchy for sex workers varied. Some worked in more upscale “parlor houses” run by a madame, while others worked independently or in the lowliest “cribs,” small, dilapidated shacks on the outskirts of town. The work was generally more dangerous than being a dance hall girl.
• Overlap: Though it was rare for a successful dance hall girl to double as a prostitute, some did. For example, Old West figure Big Nose Kate was a gambler, saloon girl, and prostitute during her life. 

Historical nuance

The historical nuance between these roles is often lost in popular media. Hollywood often portrays saloon girls and prostitutes as the same, but for women in the Old West, the distinction was a meaningful one that affected their earnings, working conditions, and social standing. While both occupations were outside the bounds of “proper” Victorian society, the dance hall profession was a legitimate and often profitable job that allowed women to earn a living with dignity.

---

Try a free look at a book from author W. W. Watson…

 Private Investigations 1: A  John Rourke Private Detective Story

by W. W. Watson © Copyright 2022

Cover Art © Copyright 2022 W. W.. Watson

This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. This book may not be re-sold or given away to other people. If you would like to share this book with another person, please purchase an additional copy for each recipient. If you are reading this book and did not purchase it, or it was not purchased for your use only, then please return to your bookseller and purchase your own copy. Thank you for respecting the hard work of this author.

LEGAL

This is a work of fiction. Any names, characters, places or incidents depicted are products of the author’s imagination. Any resemblance to actual living person’s places, situations or events is purely coincidental.

No part of this book may be reproduced by any means, electronic, print, scanner or any other means and, or distributed without the author’s permission. Permission is granted to use short sections of text in reviews or critiques in standard or electronic print.

The city lights blurred through the rain-streaked windowpane, mirroring the hazy fog in my mind. The Fields case was closed, the invoice sent, but the quiet aftermath felt heavier than any stakeout. It wasn’t the physical exhaustion, though that was considerable. Weeks of sleep deprivation had etched themselves onto my face, in the dark circles under my eyes and the stiffness in my shoulders. No, it was a deeper weariness, a hollowness that gnawed at my soul.

I’d dealt with worse, seen things that would curdle the milk in a saint’s coffee. I’d faced down thugs with shivs, navigated treacherous alleyways, and stared into the eyes of men who wouldn’t hesitate to snuff out a life. But this case… this one was different. It wasn’t the brutality, the violence, or the threat of physical harm; it was the insidious erosion of trust, the slow, creeping revelation of deceit that had left me feeling strangely… violated.

The initial excitement of the chase, the adrenaline rush of the stakeout, the satisfaction of uncovering the truth – all of that had faded, leaving behind a residue of bitterness and disillusionment. Melinda, bless her trusting soul, had confided in me, revealing her vulnerabilities, her fears, her suspicions. I’d sworn an oath, implicit though it was, to protect her, to find the truth, and to bring justice to her situation. But the truth, as it so often does, was far more complicated, far more messy, than I had anticipated.

The truth wasn’t just about Paul Fields’ infidelity; it was about corporate greed, about a web of lies woven by powerful men, about the systematic corruption that festers in the shadows of the city’s glittering façade. And I, a lone wolf in a world of sharks, had been forced to navigate that treacherous terrain, using every tool at my disposal, even the ones that left a bitter taste in my mouth.

I thought about the woman who’d arrived at the neighbor’s house, the unknown variable that had changed everything. Her presence suggested a much deeper conspiracy, a level of intrigue that extended far beyond the personal drama of a cheating husband. The investigation had morphed, evolving from a simple case of infidelity into something far more sinister, far more dangerous. The lines between right and wrong had become increasingly blurred, forcing me to make difficult choices, compromises that continue to haunt me.

The “less-than-savory sources,” as I’d vaguely termed them on the invoice, weighed heavily on my conscience. The favors I’d called in, the debts I’d incurred, were not easily forgotten. These weren’t transactions you could record in a ledger; they were unspoken agreements, exchanges of information and influence that lived in the shadows, their consequences unpredictable. There were whispers in backrooms, hushed conversations in dimly lit bars, and promises made in the dead of night that could come back to haunt me. The city was a labyrinth of such deals, and I, a seasoned traveler of its darker paths, knew the price of admission.

I rubbed my weary eyes, the stale cigarette smoke clinging to the air in my office. The silence was broken only by the rhythmic ticking of the clock, each second a tiny hammer blow against the walls of my already fragile composure. The loneliness was crushing; the burden of the case, the weight of the city’s secrets, had pressed down on me, leaving me feeling isolated, estranged even from Joan, my wife.

Joan, ever the anchor in my turbulent life, had borne witness to my late nights and erratic moods. She’d seen the strain etched onto my face, the exhaustion in my eyes, the growing distance between us. She understood the nature of my work, the shadowy corners I inhabited, but she couldn’t fully comprehend the toll it took on me, the way it slowly chipped away at my spirit, leaving me hollowed out and depleted.

I’d tried to explain, to articulate the moral ambiguity of my profession, the subtle betrayals, the compromised ethics. But words failed me. How do you explain the feeling of walking a tightrope between justice and compromise, between the need to earn a living and the desire to uphold some semblance of integrity? How do you convey the weight of a city’s secrets, the burden of its untold stories, the constant threat of danger lurking just beneath the surface?

The pay from the Fields case, while generous, couldn’t compensate for the emotional cost. It couldn’t buy back the sleep I’d lost, the peace of mind I’d sacrificed, the trust I’d begun to question. It couldn’t erase the images seared into my memory – the fleeting glimpse of fear in Melinda’s eyes, the calculated coldness in Paul Fields’ gaze, the sinister smiles exchanged in smoke-filled backrooms.

I lit another cigarette, the match a fleeting flicker in the darkness. The smoke curled upwards, a ghostly representation of my own internal turmoil. The city outside continued its relentless rhythm, oblivious to my struggles, its lights twinkling like distant stars, cold and uncaring. The case was closed, but the emotional aftermath remained, a lingering echo of the shadows I’d navigated, a testament to the price of truth, a price far exceeding the sum on the invoice.

This wasn’t just a case closed; it was a wound that wouldn’t heal easily, a scar etched onto my soul. The investigation had taken more from me than I initially anticipated. It had stolen my peace, my sleep, and a piece of my integrity. The truth was often bitter, leaving a residue of cynicism and distrust. I looked at my reflection in the window, a stranger staring back, weary and worn. The lines on my face seemed deeper, the shadows under my eyes more pronounced. The city lights outside, once a beacon of excitement, now seemed to mock my solitude.

The following days were a blur of paperwork, an attempt to regain some semblance of normalcy in my chaotic life. I responded to other inquiries, trying to immerse myself in the routine of my profession, hoping to distract myself from the emotional turmoil of the Fields case. But the memories persisted, haunting my waking hours and invading my dreams.

One evening, I found myself staring at an old photo of Joan and me, taken years ago, before the weight of the city had begun to bear down on us. We were younger, carefree, our smiles bright and unburdened. The photograph was a reminder of a simpler time, a stark contrast to the grim reality of my life now. The distance between us was palpable, a chasm carved by the relentless demands of my job, by the unspoken burdens I carried within.

I knew I had to make amends, to reconnect with Joan, to bridge the gap that had grown between us. I realized that I needed to share my burdens, to lighten the load I’d been carrying alone. I needed her strength, her compassion, her unwavering belief in me. And maybe, just maybe, with her support, I could begin to heal the emotional wounds inflicted by the Fields case, to find my way back from the shadows and into the light.

The process of healing would be slow, arduous, and require more than just a few nights’ rest. The memories would linger, but I needed to find a way to confront them, to process them, to integrate them into my life rather than let them define it. I needed to confront the moral ambiguities, the compromises I’d made. Was it worth it? The answer wasn’t simple, a clear-cut yes or no. It was a complex equation weighed against the price of justice and the cost of survival. But perhaps in confronting the cost, in acknowledging the pain, I could begin the process of healing. The city, with its darkness and secrets, would always be a part of my existence, but I wouldn’t let it consume me completely. I needed to reclaim my life, my relationships, and my sense of self.

The journey would be long, but I wouldn’t walk it alone. I would lean on Joan’s unwavering strength, her unwavering faith in me. I would find solace in simple things – the warmth of her embrace, the quiet comfort of her presence. I would remember that even in the darkest corners of the city, there was still hope, still light, still the possibility of redemption. And in that hope, I found the strength to move forward, to face the future, one step at a time, one day at a time, one case at a time. The weight of the Fields case would always be a part of me, a stark reminder of the price of truth and justice, but it would not define me. I would choose to define myself – a private investigator, a husband, a man trying to navigate the treacherous waters of life, to find his way back into the light.

The next morning, sunlight, harsh and unforgiving, sliced through the blinds, revealing the dust motes dancing in the air of my cramped office. The lingering scent of stale coffee and cigarettes hung heavy, a testament to another sleepless night. The Fields case, officially closed, continued to gnaw at me, a persistent irritant under my skin. The neat stack of paperwork on my desk, the final invoice, felt like a flimsy shield against the storm brewing inside.

It wasn’t just the moral ambiguity of the “less-than-savory sources” I’d employed; it was the unsettling feeling that something was still amiss, a loose thread dangling in the intricate tapestry of the case. The woman at the neighbor’s house, her face obscured by shadow and distance, had been a phantom, a silent specter haunting my every waking moment. Her arrival, seemingly innocuous, had shattered the neat resolution I’d presented to Melinda, leaving me with a gnawing unease that refused to be silenced.

I reread Melinda’s initial statement, her words painting a picture of a seemingly perfect marriage, cracks subtly appearing only upon closer inspection. Paul, a successful businessman, had been exhibiting increasingly erratic behavior, an odd combination of paranoia and carelessness that had raised her suspicions. He’d been unusually meticulous in checking the locks, adjusting the blinds, and scanning the street from his study window. These weren’t the actions of a man with a clear conscience, but neither did they conclusively point to infidelity.

Then there was the matter of the neighbor’s house, a seemingly ordinary dwelling that had suddenly become the focal point of my investigation. I ran a background check on the property, discovering its owner, a reclusive old woman who rarely left the house, seemingly estranged from her family. The timing of the woman’s visit, coinciding with the apparent resolution of the infidelity angle, sparked a flicker of suspicion that quickly grew into a blazing inferno of intrigue.

Driven by a renewed sense of purpose, I dusted off my contacts, the shadowy figures who operated in the city’s underbelly. These weren’t the kind of people you met in respectable establishments; they frequented dimly lit bars, backroom poker games, and seedy motels, their business conducted in hushed whispers and furtive glances. They dealt in information, secrets, and favors, and their services came at a price.

---

Private Investigations 1:

The chipped paint on my beat-up Ford was flaking like old skin. The smell of stale coffee clung to the interior like a cheap perfume…

#BookWorm #Readers #KindleUnlimited #WWWatson #Crime #Noir #Mystery #PrivateEye

---

Home: https://www.wendellsweet.com

---